| Main FC | Derbyshire (1871-1884) |
| Other FC | Marylebone Cricket Club (1870) |
| | Players of the North (1874-1877) |
| | North (1880) |
| | England (1881) |
| | Lord Sheffield's XI (1881) |
| | The Rest (1883) |
| Miscellaneous | Dudley (1869-1878) |
| | Gentlemen of Worcestershire (1869) |
| | Marylebone Cricket Club (1870) |
| | Lichfield (1870) |
| | Derbyshire (1870-1883) |
| | Wirksworth (1870) |
| | Accrington (1871) |
| | Birmingham (1873-1876) |
| | All England Eleven (1875) |
| | JTBD Platts' XI (1875) |
| | North (1875) |
| | Swansea (1876) |
| | Barrow (1876) |
| | Stockport (1877) |
| | United South of England Eleven (1877-1880) |
| | London United Eleven (1879) |
| | Leeds Clarence (1879-1880) |
| | Derbyshire XI (1879) |
| | Nuneaton (1880-1881) |
| | Skipton (1881) |
| | England XI (1881) |
| | Whitehaven (1881) |
| | Newcastle upon Tyne (1881) |
| | Frome (1882) |
| | United Eleven (1882) |
| | Players (1882) |
| | Caernarvonshire (1883) |
| | Bryn-y-Neuadd (1883) |