| Main FC | Yorkshire (1862) |
| | Yorkshire (1863-1875) |
| Other FC | All England Eleven (1862) |
| | North (1864-1865) |
| | England (1864-1868) |
| | United England Eleven (1865) |
| | Players (1868) |
| | United North of England Eleven (1875) |
| Miscellaneous | Derbyshire (1859) |
| | Yorkshire (1861-1875) |
| | Barnsley (1861) |
| | Yorkshire (1862) |
| | All England Eleven (1862-1867) |
| | Lascelles Hall (1862-1874) |
| | Yorkshire Colts (1862-1872) |
| | Batley (1862) |
| | Gomersal (1863) |
| | Huddersfield United (1863) |
| | Huddersfield (1863-1865) |
| | Otley (1863) |
| | Accrington (1864) |
| | English Eleven (1864) |
| | United England Eleven (1865-1866) |
| | Ossett (1865-1866) |
| | Boston Spa (1865) |
| | Heckmondwike (1867) |
| | Morley (1867) |
| | Yeadon (1867) |
| | Bradford (1867) |
| | North of England Eleven (1868) |
| | United South of England Eleven (1868) |
| | United North of England Eleven (1870-1876) |
| | Lancashire Professionals (1871) |
| | An Eleven (1872) |
| | Enfield (1874-1875) |
| | Yorkshire United (1876) |
| | Veterans of Yorkshire (1876) |
| | Darwen (1879-1880) |