| Main FC | Yorkshire (1862) |
| | Yorkshire (1864-1871) |
| Miscellaneous | Sheffield (1858-1865) |
| | Players Engaged at Oxford University (1859) |
| | Yorkshire (1862) |
| | Sheffield Shrewsbury Club (1862-1867) |
| | Northern Club (1863) |
| | Wakefield (1864) |
| | Scarborough (1864) |
| | All England Eleven (1864) |
| | Retford (1865) |
| | Buxton (1865) |
| | Gentlemen of the North (1865) |
| | Accrington (1866-1867) |
| | Sheffield Players Club (1866-1867) |
| | Tadcaster (1866) |
| | Whitehaven (1866) |
| | Darlington (1866) |
| | Conway Morfa (1866) |
| | Shropshire (1866) |
| | Holbeck (1866) |
| | United North and South of England Eleven (1867) |
| | Bury (1867-1868) |
| | Richmond (1867) |
| | Burnley and District (1868) |
| | Players of Lancashire (1869) |
| | Bolton (1869) |
| | Barnsley (1871) |
| | Players of the North (1871) |